Donor entitlement, and the small trades nonprofits make without noticing
A number of years ago, a family started giving their Colorado Avalanche season tickets to a local nonprofit I volunteered with. Good seats, fun games, the kind of thing that made a hard week feel a little lighter for a kid who needed it. There was one condition. Every kid who used the tickets had to write the family a thank-you letter.
On paper, that’s not much to ask. They were giving up something valuable, and they wanted to know it mattered. I understood the request. The family wanted to make sure the tickets were getting used, and used by the nonprofit’s clients.
A kid couldn’t just go to a hockey game. Going meant being identified, on paper, as one of “the program kids,” just to the family, not the public. Identified all the same, in exchange for a seat that was meant to be a thoughtful gift.
I don’t think anyone ever actually said no. You don’t turn down free Avs tickets (especially during championship years!) to protect your privacy from someone who’s clearly trying to do something kind. So year after year, the thank-yous got written, and no one even mentioned what was actually happening. I wonder if anyone even thought about it. It was a generous gift with a string attached. That string was never on any paperwork or grant agreement, and it cost something significant to the person on the receiving end.
When the Trade Gets Bigger
Sometimes that trade is a lot bigger than a letter. I worked with a donor who believed his gift entitled him to something else entirely. He didn’t want a report on outcomes or a summary of impact. He wanted conversations with the clients themselves, people who had privacy protections in place for their own safety. He didn’t ask maliciously. He believed it was a reasonable extension of what his money had already bought.
It wasn’t, and the nonprofit let them know. But the fact that he thought to ask at all says something about how giving is thought about. Let’s just call it what it is: donor entitlement.
It Isn’t Only Donors
This isn’t only something donors do. I’ve watched my own organization do it too.
We were planning our annual fundraising gala. One of our founding board members, a major donor herself, connected to nearly everyone in our database, told us early on that she judged whether she’d even attend an event by the quality of paper the invitation was printed on, not the program itself.
Ten years later, the invitation is still printed on that same expensive stock. I’m sure that most of the people involved now probably don’t even know why. She wasn’t the only one whose preferences quietly became the norm.
The event chair brought in a wave of sponsorships every year, from her own network, her own friends. Many of them didn’t pay until well after the event, sometimes months late. When it came time to follow up, she asked us not to chase the money too hard. They were her people. Pushing them on payment felt, to her, like pushing on the relationship itself.
So the team didn’t push. Real funding for the actual work sat unpaid for months, because the person who could bring it in also asked them not to. Nobody made a dramatic decision to let that happen. It just became how things worked, one gala at a time, until it wasn’t a decision anymore. That’s just how it was done.
Who the Gift Is For
None of this is fake generosity, and most of the disconnect isn’t intentional. But giving that centers the giver’s own comfort and need to be seen isn’t the same as giving that centers the person the gift is supposed to help. Most nonprofits have never felt safe enough to actually call it out, because money is money.
That’s the whole reason Epic Philanthropy exists: helping donors move past that unconscious entitlement and into a Master Giving Strategy. This creates giving that centers the actual outcome instead of the donor’s comfort, and helps nonprofits build the backbone to receive it.
If you’ve read this far, you’ve probably got a version of this in your own history, whichever side of it you’ve been on. I’d love to hear it.