Donor-Advised Funds: The Cranberry Sauce of Fundraising

Five steps to SPARK your DAF fundraising before Giving Tuesday

Donor-Advised Funds (DAFs) are like the canned cranberry sauce of fundraising: they always show up on the table, nobody likes them, and it’s hard to say ‘thank you.’

Throughout my career, I’ve seen DAF giving from three sides of the table: as a fundraiser, working at a DAF sponsor, and advising my own family’s foundation.

I can tell you this: most donors are still figuring out their 2026 charitable giving plans. Your DAF donors aren’t starting from scratch because they’ve already funded their DAFs. Now they’re deciding which organizations receive those dollars.

DAF donors are the overachievers of the giving world. They’ve already done their holiday shopping in August.

The money is already in the fund, and the donor took the tax deduction when they contributed. What’s left is deciding who gets a grant, and how easy your organization makes it to say yes.

Here’s the catch: When a grant arrives from a DAF sponsor, the name attached to it is often a financial institution, not the actual person who recommended your organization.

Your team logs the gift, thanks no one in particular, and moves on. An unidentified DAF grant is the mystery dish at the Thanksgiving potluck with no label and no way to thank the cook.

I’ve developed a framework called SPARK Your DAF Fundraising for exactly this kind of moment. It’s designed for the busiest time of year, when there’s no time for a fundraising overhaul but plenty of opportunity to make meaningful improvements. Each step can be completed in an afternoon or less.

Why bother? In fiscal year 2024, DAFs granted $64.60 billion to charities from $327.87 billion in assets. And that money moves one grant at a time, in the millions. According to the 2026 DAF Fundraising Report, approximately two-thirds of DAF gifts to participating nonprofits were under $1,000. Millions of decisions a year, made by donors your organization can reach.

So let’s stop treating DAF giving like the canned cranberry sauce of fundraising: sitting on the table every year while everyone walks past it on the way to the mashed potatoes.

S.P.A.R.K. Your DAF Fundraising

S: Show Your Legal Information

Open your website and start a timer. Can you find your organization’s legal name, EIN, and mailing address in 30 seconds or less?

A DAF donor, their advisor, and the sponsoring organization processing the grant need accurate information to identify your nonprofit. Put these details in your website footer, on your giving pages, and on a dedicated DAF page.

Name mismatches and outdated information are boring reasons to lose a grant, but they happen more often than you’d think.

I’ve spent seven holiday seasons working at a DAF sponsor and watched hundreds of grants stall, or worse, get canceled, over information that would’ve taken ten minutes to correct. Don’t let something so simple stand between your organization and a gift.

P: Pull DAF Donors From Your File and Thank Them Properly

Search your donation records for grants from Fidelity Charitable, DAFgiving360 (formerly Schwab Charitable), Vanguard Charitable, and your local community foundation.

Behind every identified DAF grant is a person who chose your organization, even if their name didn’t make it onto the paperwork. Do the detective work. Where possible, identify those donors and build the relationship.

One important reminder: DAF donors don’t receive a tax receipt from your organization. They received their tax deduction when they contributed to the fund, sometimes years earlier. Your acknowledgment should focus on gratitude and a meaningful update about the impact of their grant.

No receipt. No immediate ask. Just a genuine thank-you.

Can’t identify the donor? Thank DAF donors as a group in a newsletter, and fix the front end so the next grant arrives with a name on it. Thank them now. That’s stewardship, in every season.

A: Add Your DAF Page

Give donors one place to find everything they need to recommend a grant to your organization.

Build a dedicated DAF giving page that includes your legal name, EIN, mailing address, simple instructions, and a real human contact who knows something about DAFs.

Keep it short, current, and easy to find from your main giving page. Encourage donors to share their names and contact information with the sponsoring organization when recommending a grant, when that option is available and they’re comfortable doing so.

Think about the donor experience. If someone is ready to give but has to dig through five pages to figure out how, you’ve created unnecessary friction. The goal is simple: Remove the guesswork and make giving easy.

R: Reset Your Timing to the Off-Season

Open your 2027 calendar and put two dates on it. April and June are good starting points, although your organization’s fundraising calendar may suggest different months.

These are your DAF conversation dates. Reach out to loyal donors with a real need, a specific funding opportunity, and plenty of time to talk.

DAF grants can happen all year. Your donors aren’t limited to December, and neither should your fundraising strategy.

Think about it: Your donors are receiving countless appeals during the Giving Season. A thoughtful conversation in April or June gives you room to build a relationship without competing with dozens of other year-end requests.

Giving Season gets the reminder. Spring gets the relationship. And relationships are where repeat grants come from.

K: Keep Talking About It

From now through year-end, work DAF giving into the communication channels you’re already using.

  • One line in your year-end appeal.

  • One line in your newsletter.

  • One line at your next event.

  • One line in your thank-you letters to cash donors.

Why? Because cash donors can have DAFs, too.

You don’t need an entirely new marketing campaign. You need consistent reminders that giving through a DAF is an option. Make sure your messaging explains how donors can recommend a grant and where they can find your organization’s information.

Repetition matters. The next time a donor logs into their sponsoring organization’s portal to recommend a grant, you want your nonprofit to be top of mind.

The Short Version

Think of SPARK as a one-page checklist you can complete this week:

  • S: Show your legal information.

  • P: Pull your DAF donors and thank them properly.

  • A: Add your DAF page.

  • R: Reset your timing.

  • K: Keep talking about it.

Five manageable steps. No major overhaul required.

And remember, this isn’t just about getting more grants before December 31. It’s about building a fundraising strategy that works long after the holiday decorations come down.

If you hit a DAF question you can’t answer, I offer one-on-one DAF Therapy sessions for nonprofit leaders. Bring the question, the stalled grant, or the website page you’re unsure about. We’ll work through it together.

For organizations ready to build a more comprehensive strategy, the next Activating DAFs for Nonprofit Leaders learning cohort begins in January/February 2027. The eight-week program includes 12 strategies, practical checkpoints, and a 12-month roadmap, with coaching and collaboration along the way.

Learn more at epicphilanthropy.com/dafs.

Ready to SPARK Your DAF Fundraising?

Book a free 30-minute discovery call. We’ll talk about your organization’s goals and whether DAF Therapy or the upcoming cohort is the right next step.

Be Epic this giving season!

P.S. Looking for a fun way to bring generosity into your Thanksgiving gathering? I created Second Helpings, a free Thanksgiving giving game for families. Twelve cards, a Pardon and a Seconds wildcard, and one very serious $1 million decision. Check it out here.

Next
Next

Nice Seats, Just One Catch